Tiffany
Pre-Loved Tiffany Return to Tiffany
The heart tag that made minimalist jewellery a household name
Return to Tiffany pieces are an easy, low-risk entry into pre-loved fine jewellery: sterling silver and gold pieces resist tarnish and damage well, so second-hand examples usually show only light, easily polished wear. Because so many pieces were produced across decades, buyers can be choosy about condition and still find good prices.
Live listings
96 pieces
Sourcing
Resale marketplaces & specialist resellers
Live listings — 96 pieces
Prices are sellers' asking prices. Nuvinty may earn a commission if you buy through a link. How we earn
96 of 96 shown
Tiffany
Return to Tiffany & Co. 4.5g 18k Gold Diamond Heart Pendant 16" Necklace
£1,779.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co Sterling Silver 70g Rolo Chain • Return To Tiffany Pendant • 40.5cm
£999.99
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
TIFFANY & CO. 18K Gold Return to Tiffany Oval Tag Bracelet
£3,066.70
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return to Tiffany® Heart Tag Toggle Necklace RRP £1125
£664.60
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co 925 Silver Heart Tag Bead 16" Necklace, Hallmarked
£603.40
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co Return To Tiffany Oval Tag Necklace Bracelet 925 Silver Set
£567.69
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co Silver Heart Choker Necklace 15.5" Retail £990+ Genuine
£559.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co Sterling Silver Heart Tag Necklace 15.5" Retail £990+
£549.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co Sterling Silver Heart Tag Choker Necklace 17"Retail £990+
£549.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co Heart Tag Toggle 16” Necklace 925 Sterling Silver Assay
£516.70
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co Sterling Silver Heart Tag Necklace 15.5" Retail £990+
£485.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Authentic TIFFANY & Co. Return to TIFFANY & Co. Necklace 18 Carat 18K Solid Gold
£4,710.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Tag Charm Necklace
£699.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany heart tag toggle necklace in silver
£822.70
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co. Heart Tag 4mm Bead Ball 16" Silver Necklace, RRP £690
£387.99
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co. Silver Heart Tag Bead 18" Necklace, RRP £690, Hallmarked
£387.99
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co Heart Tag 16” Necklace Choker Sterling Silver 925 Genuine
£375.94
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Iconic "Return to Tiffany™" Heart Tag Set
£669.70
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Tag 925 Sterling Silver Toggle Necklace
£516.70
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return to Tiffany Wrap Bead Bracelet in Silver with Pearls and a Diamond
£618.70
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co Return to Tiffany Blue Enamel Heart Silver Bead Necklace RRP £645
£300.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Authentic Vintage Tiffany & Co Return To Tiffany Round Tag Bracelet
£291.90
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co Heart Tag Toggle 8” 20cm 925 Sterling Silver Genuine
£280.46
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co Medium 925 Return to Tiffany HeartTag Pendant Necklace 50cm H marks
£271.10
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany Heart Tag Key Pendant Necklace Sterling Silver With Box Pouch
£250.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co 925 Please Return To Tiffany Mini Padlock Heart Beaded Bracelet
£250.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Tag 925 Sterling Silver Cable Necklace
£618.70
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co Return to Tiffany 925 Sterling Silver Heart Tag Bead Necklace
£450.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return to Tiffany Pink Heart Tag Bead Bracelet Sterling Silver With Box Pouch
£220.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return to Tiffany & Co. Double Mini Enamel Heart Pendant Silver 16" Necklace
£217.99
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return to Tiffany Sterling Silver LOVE Padlock charm Bracelet 7.3" RARE Genuine
£429.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany 925 Sterling Silver Heart Tag Toggle Bracelet
£208.70
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany and Co Silver Return To Tiffany Heart Pendant On 17” Ball Link Chain
£208.69
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany 925 Sterling Silver Heart Tag Bead Bracelet
£208.70
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany 925 Sterling Silver Heart Tag Pendant Necklace
£208.70
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Charm Necklace 925 Silver Black Cord
£208.70
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Genuine Tiffany & Co. 'Return to Tiffany' Round Tag Necklace & Bracelet Set
£409.60
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co Blue Silver Heart Tag Bead Bracelet 925 With Box Pouch
£200.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co Blue Enamel Double Mini Heart Tag Necklace 925 With Box
£200.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co Please Return To Tiffany Blue Enamel 925 Heart Charm With Box Pouch
£200.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return to Tiffany & Co Hardwear 925 Sterling Silver Bead Necklace & Bracelet Set
£516.70
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Authentic Tiffany and Co Charm- Return to Tiffany Heart Padlock Charm Pendant
£182.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co. Sterling Silver Heart On Silver Beaded Necklace 16"Rare
£291.90
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany 925 Sterling Silver Chain Bracelet Round Tag
£353.50
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co Sterling Silver Oval Choker Tag Necklace 15.5" genuine
£349.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return to Tiffany & Co Silver Blue Enamel Heart Bracelet 7.5"Medium/Rare Genuine
£349.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Sterling Silver 925 Return To Tiffany Heart Pendant Necklace Small
£165.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co Return to Tiffany Silver Toggle Bracelet – Black Titanium Heart
£420.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co Return to Tiffany Heart Tag 925 Silver Necklace Boxed
£156.70
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany 925 Sterling Silver Heart Tag Necklace Toggle
£300.05
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return to Tiffany & Co Silver Oval Tag Bracelet 7.3" Medium Retail £690 Genuine
£297.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return to Tiffany & Co Silver Heart Tag Bracelet 7.5" Medium Retail £690 Genuine
£297.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Authentic Tiffany & Co BRACELET - Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Bracelet 19cm
£296.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
TIFFANY & CO Return To Tiffany Heart Tag Bracelet Sterling Silver 925 w/Box -MLY
£295.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return to Tiffany & Co Silver Heart Tag Bracelet 7.5" Medium Retail £690 Genuine
£295.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co. Ball Beaded Silver Heart 8mm 7.5 inches Bracelet
£289.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Toggle Necklace Sterling Silver 925
£299.18
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Charm Bracelet Sterling Silver 925
£199.88
via eBay
Ships from the US · UK import VAT likely
Tiffany
Authentic Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Chain Bracelet
£291.90
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co Blue Enamel Silver Double Hearts Necklace 18" Extendable
£239.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co. Sterling Silver Heart On Silver Beaded Necklace 20"Rare
£229.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany Large Silver Heart Pendant Necklace
£228.46
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return To Tiffany Oval Tag Necklace Choker 38cm
£219.10
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return to Tiffany & Co. RARE Silver circle Pendant with 2 hearts 18" Necklace
£213.90
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Tag & Key 925 Sterling Silver Necklace
£167.10
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co Return To Tiffany Heart And Rubedo Key With Chain 925
£199.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Tag 925 Sterling Silver Chain Bracelet
£156.70
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co Return To Tiffany Heart Tag Toggle Necklace Sterling Silver 61.10g
£190.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co 925 Return To Tiffany Oval Ring With Box Pouch
£190.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co Silver Pink Double Mini Hearts Necklace 16" Retail £300
£189.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co Silver Blue Heart Tag Mini Bead Bracelet 7"Medium Genuine
£189.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
6.5" Tiffany & Co Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Bracelet Sterling Silver 925
£181.71
via eBay
Ships from the US · UK import VAT likely
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co Sterling Silver Heart Tag Necklace 15.5" Retail £840+
£459.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co Silver Double Mini Hearts Necklace 16" Retail £300+ Tax
£179.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. "Return to Tiffany" Chain Bracelet. Round Charm. Sterling Silver
£177.49
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Toggle Bracelet #70905
£260.70
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. - Return to Tiffany Double Hearts Pendant & 16in Chain -925 Silver
£159.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Pendant Necklace Sterling Silver 925
£156.70
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Toggle Necklace and Bracelet Set | 925
£798.22
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany 925 Sterling Silver Bead Bracelet Blue Heart
£172.30
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany&Co Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Chain Bracelet 925 Sterling Silver M
£172.30
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Key Pendant Necklace 925 Silver 18in
£312.70
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co Hallmarked Silver Return To Tiffany Choker with Oval Tag
£259.66
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Authentic Tiffany&Co Return to Tiffany Heart Toggle Necklace Sterling Silver 16”
£486.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Authentic Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Long Heart Tag Necklace
£216.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Return To Tiffany & Co Sterling Silver Round Disc Tag Bracelet 7.75" Genuine
£203.50
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany’s Silver Choker “Please return to Tiffany & Co.”
£207.66
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Tag 925 Sterling Silver Bead Bracelet
£297.10
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co Return To Tiffany Heart Tag Beaded 4mm, 16” Necklace
£363.42
via eBay
Ships from the US · UK import VAT likely
Tiffany
Return to Tiffany & Co. Sterling Silver Double Mini Heart Tag Necklace 41cm
£165.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Necklace
£167.10
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany & Co.
Tiffany & Co. Return To Tiffany Sterling Silver Toggle Bracelet
£310.00
via The Luxury Closet
Ships from Dubai · import duty may apply
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Full Heart Tag 925 Silver pendant necklace
£225.34
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Bracelet 925 SS 7” w pouch box RRP 605
£213.90
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Vintage Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Necklace – Sterling Silver
£203.50
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
Tiffany
Tiffany & Co Return to Tiffany Heart Tag 925 Sterling Silver Toggle Bracelet 30g
£199.00
via eBay
Ships from the UK · no import charges
eBay listings here are refreshed daily (the oldest was last checked at 07:30, 13 Oct, UK time), so details can differ from eBay. Check the listing on eBay before buying.
Tiffany Return to Tiffany auctions ending soon
All Tiffany auctions →
TiffanyTiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Bracelet 925 Sterling Silver Lobster£11818 bidsEnds
The oldest bid shown was last updated from eBay at 19:18, 13 Oct (UK time), so the live bid on eBay may be higher. We refresh auctions several times a day.
Live eBay auctions; the current bid and the seller's terms are on eBay. Affiliate links.
Why the Return to Tiffany is iconic
Introduced in the late 1960s and revived to major popularity in the late 1990s, the Return to Tiffany line is defined by its engraved heart or oval tag reading "Please Return to Tiffany & Co.", a nod to the brand's early dog-tag-style jewellery for lost valuables. Its simple, wearable design made it one of the brand's best-selling collections ever.
Checking the price
Compare the live listings above for current asking prices — price is driven mostly by size, materials, condition and completeness (box, receipt, authenticity card).
Sizes & variants
Available as necklaces, bracelets and earrings in heart, oval and round tag shapes; sterling silver is most common, with 18ct gold and bean-shaped variants also sought.
How to authenticate
- 1.Check the hallmark stamp reading "Tiffany & Co." alongside the sterling silver (925) or gold marking.
- 2.Look closely at the engraving depth and font; genuine pieces have crisp, evenly weighted lettering, not shallow or uneven stamping.
- 3.Inspect the clasp and jump rings for Tiffany's characteristic solid, well-finished hardware rather than a lightweight aftermarket replacement.
Guidance only — always buy from sellers offering an authentication guarantee.
Buying a pre-owned Tiffany Return to Tiffany — FAQs
Does silver Tiffany jewellery tarnish?
Sterling silver can tarnish over time but responds well to gentle polishing, so light tarnish is not a concern.
Is the heart tag the original design?
The tag shape has varied over the decades; heart and oval are the most iconic and widely reissued.
Are these pieces a good gift choice pre-loved?
Yes, provided the hallmark and engraving are verified, as the pieces are simple, durable and hold sentimental appeal.
Before you buy
Explore more pre-owned